Wednesday, 31 August 2011

* Pimp my Mendel * - How to build up a LM8UU Linear Bearing Prusa

Mendel Bling is built up and running better, smoother and faster than I imagined possible.

I decided to make the Bling machine build to be a complete as possible manufacturing solution and also add a few upgrades and ease of use changes along the way, let me know what you think. It’s also a full linear bearing (LM8UU) design on all the axis.


I’m also going to use this as a *basic* overview ‘How to build a Prusa Mendel’ post, hopefully it will help someone or at least give you some ideas for your own build.
I does not cover every step, just highlights many of the main assembly points.

Frame Vertex -
My frame vertexes are a little chunkier than the normal Prusa versions, the only thing to make sure is that you have the same measurement between all frame vertex plastic faces, so if that’s 250mm like the ‘official’ Prusa or 252mm or 246mm like mine then that’s fine, just make sure they are all the same.

Axis lower frame Assembly.
Axis lower frame back with Y motor mount.
X-Carriage - 
This is Greg's X carriage fitted with 3 x LM8UU Linear bearings.

The X carriage assembly with Z ends –
Both the Prusa Z ends are a tight push-fit, I recommend wrapping just the end of the bar in Kapton tape then slightly softening the plastic before pushing it in and holding the plastic in compression against the bar until it goes cold and sets, the wrapped Kapton tape will make it impossible to remove without re-heating, so make sure you push the bars all the way into the Z end, and do one end at a time.

REMEMBER to slide on your X carriage with it’s Linear bearings before attaching into the push-fit ends of the Z axis parts.

Y stage –
If you use Greg’s LM8UU Y axis holders then assemble them in a similar way to this, there are other variants (Joem_)that have mounting lugs etc. so take your pick.

Slide them (carefully) onto the Y stage bars and space them on your frame.

So after making sure your Y axis bars are parallel, straight and spaced appropriately you can screw the Y plate onto your Linear bearing holders.

Keep going, in a short while it will start to look something like this.

The Print bed –
I slightly modified the MDF print bed by adding small wooden bars at both the Y axis ends and spray painting it with high temperature paint, you don’t need to do this, I just wanted to eliminate any flex and also have a slight lip in the Y axis direction to stop extra air movement under the bed and also over the top of the heated surface.

I added a sheet of Aluminium foil 
And then a cut sheet of silicon (kitchen baking silicon)
After this if you can get hold of it (£1 from you local pound shop) I added a sheet of PTFE cooking mesh, this stuff is great, 260 Degrees C rated. Lightweight thermal isolation and insulation for your heated bed.



The heated bed is a normal Prusa FR4 PCB; I’m going to use it upside down with the heating tracks on the top surface, so to protect the tracking and smooth it out I covered the bed in PET tape.
Top TIP – Adding the Tape (PET or Kapton) to this side of the PCB has another major advantage, any air bubbles trapped when you put the tape on make their way down the gaps in the tracks so you end up with a really nice surface, bubble free.

If you use the other side it’s not easy so apply the tape and you still end up with an impression of the PCB silk-screen printing text appearing on all your printed parts!

The stack of Alu foil, silicon sheet and PTFE mesh will give you a gap between the MDF and heating PCB, so you need to make sure you have the same spacing or a little more for the four mounting points.
Here I have used M3 stainless steel bolts, nuts and a PTFE washer to get the correct spacing.

Z Motors-
The Z drive motor connections are Nophead’s design, these work well and only need a small section of plastic tube around the motor shaft, heat it up if it’s tight to fit onto the shaft.
These should be done up tightly around the motor shaft and the M8 studding using all four bolts on each.

Z stage –
To install the Linear bearings into the Z stage you may need to heat the plastic slightly, it makes it a little easier to click them in and you can make sure they ‘set’ tightly in place and in alignment if you also use a M8 rod while you fit them in place. Secure with ty-wraps.



The motor mounts for the Z stage are both designed to have 4 bolts connecting the motors tightly down, no one actually seems to use these and it is preferable to ty-wrap the Z motors in place to allow them to ‘decouple’ mechanical wobble from Z movements.

I started by only securing with 2 bolts and using PTFE washers, but after a few prints I also ended up using ty-wraps so the motors are floating other than being held in place with ty-wraps.


The next time I take it apart I will also put a sheet of silicon in between the motors and the mount to further decouple any vibrations.

Also when you install the Z motors and the very straight M8 studding remember to add a spring inside both sides of the hexagon sections, it should be under compression between the top and bottom M8 nuts so when you do Z moves it reduces backlash to an absolute minimum.

I also added Rod stabilisers to my machines top and bottom of the Z drive rods.

I think they do help support the Z transport very well and help with vertical alignment, but you don’t really need them.



Belts and pulleys -
I have used off-the-shelf Metal pulleys this time as it’s using the 2.5mm belts and I didn’t have time to cast more of the fine pitch pulleys, I also wanted to see how tricky it was to drill and tap the metal pulleys, it’s not hard, anyone with a drill press and a simple hand tap could do it.

Top left shows how they come, you need to drill them out and add another hole for the grub screw and tap that with M3

Attach the pulleys to the motor shafts and use a good quality grub screw to keep it in place.


Greg’s X carriage has an in-built tensioner system.


Install the Y belt and if you keep the Y belts long enough so you can pull, adjust and tighten them even after the build platform is on then you should not have to disassemble anything to tighten belts in the future. 
I just taped the spare ends down to keep them tidy.

The extruder is Greg’s design along with my own Fan duct mounted on the X carriage.




The hot-end heater block is my version here - 

Electronics –
I’m not going to explain how to make up the electronics here as there is very good documentation on the Wiki and also everyone seems to have a different preference with electronics and there are so many variants.
I did have some new (at the time) RAMPS 1.3 PCB’s but I decided to use up the last 1.2 PCB I had as they are not very different in reality.

I plan to use the 1.3 Versions in a future dual extruder machine that will look quite different to this machine.

I’m housing the wiring and electronics in a simple ABS case (175mm x 110mm x 66mm).




Neat wiring and cable identification is a good thing to make it easier in the future.


RAMPS installed and some of the stepsticks for testing.

Make sure you have nice chunky wires and good crimps for your +12V power connections to the electronics.

RAMPS V1.2 does not have a separate Poly-fuse for the Heated bed, This one is 11A rated and connected separately to another set of +12V wires from the ATX PSU and then on to the heated bed, the return from the heated bed goes to the H-bed MOSFET sink (GND) on the electronics.

These are simple mechanical endstops to my own design, but you can use whatever switches you have or opto-endstops if you prefer.

I added a few LED indicators so I can see when the power to the system is on, the heated bed is active and the hot-end is being driven, I recommend doing this it tells you a lot about how your system is working and is nice to check things happen when you expect them.

When running from SD cards it’s always nice to be able to quickly remove the card to update Gcode, so I decided to extend the SD cable to the outside of the enclosure in an easy to access spot. 
To do this I simply used a cut-down Ribbon cable (an old PC Floppy drive cable) and fitted a male connector so I can fit the SD card adapter. I have not had any problems doing this, but keep this ‘extension’ as short as possible.

I’m using Stepstick motor drivers in this machine, they are almost identical to the Pololu versions, and in the photo you can see both the Pololu (top left) and Stepstick below.

Think about cable strain relief and give yourself plenty of cable to allow free movement especially on the Z axis and the extruder assembly.
Added an on/off switch for the ATX psu (this is on the low-voltage side, instead of just wiring it to ground to get the ATX to turn on), it can be classes as a panic button also as it will shut down all motors and heated things.

To mount everything and as a frame for a filament spool I use some 20mm T-slot Aluminium, you could just as easily use wood or threaded bar for this ‘extension’. The Mendel is fixed to this via 4 x 8mm printed plastic mounts at the base and two small M8 threaded rods for extra stability using the normal Mendel mounting plate at the top. The electronics box and ATX psu are all mounted to the t-slot frame.


At the very top there is space for a standard 30cm filament spool using another M8 threaded rod. This means the whole thing can be picked up and easily moved all you need is power and a USB cable that can also be removed after you set off a print using the onboard SD card.

Finally four rubber feet to minimise vibration and noise .

Software and firmware is your choice, and many more are on their way as I write this, I’m using Sprinter and Printrun (Pronterface) along with Skeinforge V41 but people are starting to use SFACT, I just had a quick go and it has much easier to understand names for the settings, and a lot less ratio's, so be sure to check it out.

First print.
It’s first print was successful and it went on to print all my multi-coloured things a few posts back.
It’s now going to be hard at work making more stuff and of course a grandchild…

Thanks for reading, I hope it was useful.

Rich.

25 comments:

  1. Awesome writeup of how the latest modifications fit into the Prusa! Really useful stuff.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Very nice looking machine Rich! And a fantastic writeup too. This is definitely going to be one of my favorite reference RepRaps as I start to work on my next one.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks for the informative post. I'm in the process of building a similar Prusa (reprap-fab.org deluxe version with lm8uu).

    Did you have any trouble getting y-axis table to move smootly? Did you add any oil to the rods?

    I'm getting some trouble getting a smooth ride on mines.

    Thanks,

    Miguel

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thanks everyone for the positive comments.

    Hi Miguel, nice website and I hope the Deluxe Prusa works out, the Linear bearings really do make a big difference.
    I didn't have any issues with the Y table moving smoothly or any other axis, the LM8UU's feel a like they are grinding when you first install them, but really they are gliding well, and after a short while bed in really well. I have only lubricated them once with Triflow (Teflon oil).

    ReplyDelete
  5. I'll give it some time and oil. Grinding is a good definition for the type of sound I was getting :-) It is reassuring to know that they will glide soon.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Have you found the x-axis rods like 95mm too long (mine are). If so, how did you cut them?

    ReplyDelete
  7. One machine has hardened steel rods 400mm (I didn't cut them!) the other is 406mm 'official' Prusa size, but my next machine is going to be 450mm so I can fit a dual extruder and X-carriage and have a little more room but still a 200x200mm print area.

    As long as they line up with the Top rods (you will need to space the Z motor mounts out a bit) most langths should work.

    I cut Stainless with a normal hack-saw just fine with a bit of WD40 and some masking tape.

    ReplyDelete
  8. It looks like you didn't use any bed-springs initially, as those are one of my biggest concerns regarding wobble on the y-axis. How did it work out for you?
    Keep up the good work!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Very nice work, I always take a look at your blog!
    Just a question: do you use rod stabilisers at top and bottom of the Z rods? (different thing in text and picture...) and how long is your z print travel with that rod stabilisers?
    thanks for your help!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Hi Tom - Sorry I missed these posts - I did have bed springs, but at first the 'normal' pen springs - they are really bad, don't use them it's just wobble and poor print quality. You need to use a half decent bed spring, something similar to what is used on an extruder, if not the same.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Hi Pacca, sorry a bit late with this reply - I have used both just at the bottom and just at the top, at the moment I use them on both ends and it works well. by far the biggest difference was using better bed springs. I expect that I could now remove the Rod stabilisers now and it would not make much difference.
    With both fitted I get 71.75mm of build height, I could get 3-4mm more but then I may as well remove the top ones and get 17mm more.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Sweet Prusa!

    Two quick questions. What's the total on the LM8UU, 9? 3X, 4Y, 2Z? Or am I missing a bushing somewhere?

    Also, I have a ToM with a .4mm nozzle (MK7) and I'm extremely happy with the print quality. I've only seen 1 prusa in person and the print quality was nowhere near my ToM. But he wasn't using an MK7 extruder. Is there any reason that a Prusa wouldn't print with as nice a resolution as a ToM if it were to use the same hot end? Would it possibly print better than the ToM using the same hot end?

    If the Prusa will print as well as the ToM with the proper setup, I'm going to use my ToM to create one because I'd love the larger print bed.

    Thanks in advance!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks.

      You have 4 on the Y axis (the print bed) 2 on each side of the Z axis (4) and a choice of using 3 or 4 on the X carriage (I now use 4 all the time) so you really need 12 x LM8UU linear bearings for a good setup.

      I have seen quite a few TOM prints, they are very nice with a MK7, but I still think you have more control, resolution and can get better overall quality with a very well tuned Prusa, the Hot-end and a good (Geared) extruder makes all the difference.

      For ultra low layers, a Geared Greg/Wade style extruder gives better results than a direct drive (MK7 / V9) type of drive.

      You should make one, the BIG print bed is great, you'll never go back...

      Delete
  13. Excellent Job! Thanks for creating a sensible topic that suits the taste of your readers. Keep up the good Work. babbit bearings

    ReplyDelete
  14. Cards become more efficient through using this idea...

    ReplyDelete
  15. I really like your all the points the design which you have mention are very important.
    Modern technologies permit to go for plastic cards since there are millions and billion or design with different color combination, material. i love your style :-)

    ReplyDelete
  16. Thanks for the article, it is very instructive. I found this website if you would like to read further information: http://www.directindustry.com/industrial-manufacturer/ball-bearing-61604.html

    ReplyDelete